Number of components in Space rule

[aabbaspoor]

Hi all,

I have problem with rule I want to make. I already had contact with someone from Solibri but unfortunatley he couldnt help me.

So this is the deal. I want to create a rule that checks whether a toilet or a bathroom has a toilet bowl.

The rule should check whether an apartment space contains a toilet space.

• If a toilet space is found, it should then check whether that space contains a toilet bowl.

• If no toilet space is found, the rule should then look for a bathroom space within the apartment.

  • list itemlist itemIf a bathroom space is found, it should check whether that space contains a toilet bowl.

I have created this

The first one:

• is looking for space toilet and then number of components
  (this works)

The second:

• First looking for space toilet, sub rule: Check only passed components
• If no space toilet, look for space bathroom: sub rule: Check only failed components
• Then check if there is a toilet bowl in the space

Now this isnt working properly. It says OK, like there is NO ISSUE. I have said minimum 20 bowls in the space and still it says OK NO ISSUES

I Hope i will get some help here

[aroesti]

Not sure I understand but I thinkg the gatekeeper rule you have created doesnt work well.
you shuld look for “check component” view and see if the first rule pass the relevent elements.

follow this
https://help.solibri.com/hc/en-us/articles/4415773412247-Using-Gatekeeper-Rules-to-Filter-Components-into-Sub-Rules

[aabbaspoor]

@aroesti Thank you

But I do this exact the same as the link.

The first rule checks if there is a toilet space in the appartement space. Sub rule i have chosen is Check only passed components
It means if it finds space toilet in appartment space, its a fail and will not pass it forward. It only pass forward if in the appartment has NO toilet space.

The second rule checks if there is a bathroom space (if not found toilet space). The sub rule is check only failed components
It means it will pass forward if it finds a bathroom space in the appartment space

It will use these failed components to check the number of components

This is what I understand.

[aroesti]

Why dont you use 225 to check that all toilet space and bathroom space have at least 1 toilet bowl?

[aabbaspoor]

@aroesti Because I will get issues if a bathroom doesnt have a toilet bowl, even when there is a toilet space with a bowl.

I want it like: if there is no toilet space, than check bathroom for a toilet bowl.

[aroesti]

can you share IFC of a specific floor in your building?
It relly depands on the way you modeling.
for example, do you have a space that represents the entire apartment? you can use this to check …